Aug 20, 2025
Mitch Caplan’s career is a testament to the power of visionary leadership and the transformative impact of technology on financial services. From launching the first branchless bank, Telebanc, to steering E-Trade through the internet boom and the 2008 financial crisis, Caplan has been at the forefront of financial innovation. As the interim CEO of Yieldstreet, he continues to lead and shape the evolving landscape of fintech. Here’s a look at the leadership lessons, challenges, and triumphs he’s experienced over a career spanning several decades.
The Rise of Telebanc: Innovation in a Changing Industry
Caplan’s journey into fintech began in the early '90s, when he co-founded Telebanc. In an era when physical branches were the norm, Caplan saw the potential for a new model: a branchless bank. He and his team took a bold step by acquiring a small, struggling bank and transforming it into a fully remote, internet-based institution. With no physical branches, Telebanc offered competitive rates and FDIC insurance, pioneering the future of online banking.
“We were at the right place at the right time. We had a great team, we focused on disciplined execution,” Caplan recalls. Over the next decade, Telebanc grew from $50 million in assets to $8 billion, eventually going public and becoming the largest internet bank at the time.
The E-Trade Acquisition: Turning Adversity into Opportunity
In the mid-'90s, Caplan’s company merged with E-Trade in a deal that would change the trajectory of online financial services. Though he initially saw the merger as a way for Telebanc to thrive within a larger asset-gathering organization, Caplan soon found himself at the helm of E-Trade. During the internet bubble and subsequent financial crisis, Caplan navigated the company through rough waters by slashing costs, improving efficiency, and strategically acquiring other firms.
“We had to cut, literally, a billion dollars of cost out of this business,” Caplan recalls. Caplan’s leadership at E-Trade exemplified a key lesson: decisive action during crises can turn adversity into growth. His approach, grounded in transparency and a willingness to make tough decisions, was instrumental in E-Trade’s survival and eventual success.
Leadership and the Role of Trust: Building High-Performing Teams
A core theme in Caplan’s leadership philosophy is the importance of trust. Whether working with regulators, employees, or board members, he believes in the power of honest, transparent communication. Caplan’s ability to inspire and lead high-performing teams became especially apparent when E-Trade faced severe challenges during the financial crisis.
Instead of making reactive, top-down decisions, he engaged the team in a collaborative process that focused on restructuring the business for long-term growth. By creating a culture of accountability and clear communication, Caplan ensured that the company’s leadership remained united in their vision.
The Evolving Role of Fintech: Embracing Innovation and Adaptability
Caplan’s ability to pivot and adapt to technological changes has been key to his success. He has seen firsthand how technology can disrupt traditional industries, particularly in banking and investing. From his early days at Telebanc to his role at E-Trade, and now at Yieldstreet, Caplan has witnessed and actively driven the democratization of financial services.
His perspective on technology as a tool for empowerment is central to his work at Yieldstreet, where he continues to advocate for making private market assets accessible to all investors.
Yieldstreet: Democratizing Investment Opportunities
At Yieldstreet, Caplan is focused on expanding access to alternative investments that were once reserved for institutional investors. As the platform continues to grow, Caplan emphasizes the importance of not only providing investment opportunities but also educating users on the benefits of diversifying their portfolios.
“We have to educate why private markets make sense for you in building a truly diversified portfolio,” Caplan explains. “And then, why Yieldstreet? Why do we have the right to earn your loyalty and trust as a client?”
Advice for Entrepreneurs and Investors: Lessons Learned
Throughout his career, Caplan has learned valuable lessons that are crucial for entrepreneurs and investors alike. His advice for founders is simple yet powerful: “There’s nothing wrong with failing, just fail fast. The minute you try something, learn it. If it’s working, double down; if it’s not, course correct.”
Final Thoughts: A Legacy of Service-First Leadership
Mitch Caplan’s story is a powerful reminder that true leadership is about more than just achieving success; it’s about fostering trust, staying adaptable in the face of change, and always thinking about the bigger picture. Whether he’s steering a startup through a crisis or championing the next wave of financial technology, Caplan’s approach is rooted in service-first leadership that focuses on empowering others and building long-term, sustainable growth.
For more insights from Mitch Caplan on leadership, innovation, and the future of financial services, tune into the full episode on Electrifying Growth.
Interested in guest-starring on Electrifying Growth? Apply Here to be a guest!
